Be Careful What You Believe

In Ideological Warfare, pseudo-science is rampant. Students and scientists themselves are far from being immune from it. On the contrary, they are too often a valuable, easy pray for pseudo-scientific claims, effectively recruiting them for ideological battles that have little or nothing to do with science, education or even rationality at all.

Looking at this table, it’s easy to convince yourself that smarter, more educated people tend to be Democrats, and uneducated ones, instead, Republicans. Are this data really a proof of that?

Since a couple of weeks, this table is circulating on the web along with claims that educated people tend to be Democrats, and uneducated ones are, instead, Republicans.

Data shown in the picture, taken alone, can actually be interpreted both ways. For example, just suppose educated people are mostly republicans. Romney’s support for, say, Intelligent Design, could have made them decide simply not to vote.

Both candidates actually scored poorly in science issues (Romney was worst, but Obama is dangerously near to vaccination deniers!), and abstentionism was an issue for both parties. Not-to-vote decision by our hypothetical highly-educated, republican people, would have had minor impact in low-education states, but could have been enough to tilt results in high-education ones.

Regardless of the likelihood of this particular hypothesis, what I’m pointing out is, that what it’s shown in the table is just a useless incomplete data set.

Nonetheless, it is presented in a way that looks like a sound proof for something, at least to the eyes of the very large majority of people with little expertise in social sciences. Moreover, you should remember that scientists are people, and not all degrees are in social science or economy. Unless a scientist have a specific expertise in the subject, her/his opinion about society models – all other things being equal – have the same value of everyone else’s. Albert Einstein, for example, was a strong advocate for Russia’s communism.

Politicians realized long ago that scientists’ approval pays in votes. Actually, just being seen as liked by scientists is enough. Pseudo-scientific stuff like this table, are indeed the tip of the iceberg of a long, strenuous effort put up by politicians all around the world to ‘recruit’ scientists – and, in a sense, science as a whole – to their own ideological cause.

Stuff like this picture have nothing to do with education or science; it’s just useless, detrimental ideological propaganda, in (pseudo)science disguise.

Now you know. Be careful what you believe.


Informazioni su WorldsOutsideReality

«Hold faithfulness and sincerity as first principles. Have no friends not equal to yourself. When you feel you have faults, do not hesitate to correct yourself.» (Confucius; Analects, 9.25)

Pubblicato il 21 novembre 2012, in A Little Bit of This and That, DibattitoScienza, Evidence-based policy, Parlando di scienza con tag , , , , , , , , , . Aggiungi il permalink ai segnalibri. Lascia un commento.


Inserisci i tuoi dati qui sotto o clicca su un'icona per effettuare l'accesso:


Stai commentando usando il tuo account Chiudi sessione / Modifica )

Foto Twitter

Stai commentando usando il tuo account Twitter. Chiudi sessione / Modifica )

Foto di Facebook

Stai commentando usando il tuo account Facebook. Chiudi sessione / Modifica )

Google+ photo

Stai commentando usando il tuo account Google+. Chiudi sessione / Modifica )

Connessione a %s...

Due Minuti di Lucidità

Il Blog di Guido Saraceni


Trails of thoughts worth following

The Constitutional Renaissance Call

It is up to the states to fix it.

Hic Rhodus

Hic Salta!

Casi paologici

Fatti, idee e situazioni più o meno paradossali


Sotto il camice, una persona con i propri sogni e le proprie passioni

Futura Psi

Il blog di due studentesse di psicologia

Scholarly Open Access

Critical analysis of scholarly open-access publishing

Humble Nations

Kindle Ebook Pre-made Book Cover Design, Commissions and My Fiction

Il Blog del Ninth

Poche ragazze da quelle parti.

Lou Del Bello

science journalist


Quelli che cacciamo dalle case e sterminiamo nelle città sono modelli molto preziosi per la ricerca biomedica.


Non mi seguite... se vi perdete è colpa vostra

Dott.ssa Ilaria Rizzo



Piccola bottega naturalistica


Salute del fisico, benessere della mente, bellezza del corpo. Articoli monotematici di medicina a cura del dott. Emilio Alessio Loiacono

Io non ci volevo venire!

Non lo so, poi ci penso.


il blog di Stefano Paparozzi

A sparkler in the dark

Pensieri, divulgazione e condivisione...

Io Non Faccio Niente

il blog di un ricercatore INFN


Semplifichiamo la complessità

in italiano

Le parole sono suoni per coloro che non s'impegnano; sono il nome di esperienze per chi le vive (L. Giussani)


Sorridi! Sei sul miglior sito per acquistare e-book di argomento naturalistico

Mountain Bike Maintenance

Fix your own bike...

giornalismo & comunicazione...

... in agricoltura...

Nature's Poisons

Mother nature is out to get us

Lo Spirito Del Tempo

La difficoltà non sta nel credere alle nuove idee ma nel rifuggire dalle vecchie

Massimo D'Angeli

“When most people agree with you, worry” (“Quando la maggioranza delle persone concorda con te, preoccupati“) Julian Rappaport, psicologo

Wellcome Trust Blog

Life from a Wellcome Trust perspective

Stuff And Nonsense

Blogging about balderdash and baloney

Conferenza Nazionale sull'Energia

Energie per l'Italia del Futuro

Health & Family

A healthy balance of the mind, body and spirit

%d blogger hanno fatto clic su Mi Piace per questo: